Some services axed, others saved as Newport council tries to bridge budget gap

FACING FUNDING AXE: Gwent Music Support Service FACING FUNDING AXE: Gwent Music Support Service

A NEWPORT leisure centre will close and funding for a music service will be axed as part of plans to bridge a £7 million gap in the 2013/14 council budget.

But two care homes were given a short-term reprieve and a library will be saved, cabinet members agreed yesterday.

Meanwhile residents can expect a 3.5 per cent council tax rise if the budget proposals are agreed by full council next week. The city council aims to close Hillside Care Home in Gaer by 2015/16 but following meetings with users and their families, members agreed that those currently living there would not be forced to move if they do not want to. New Willows respite care home is also set to close in the next few years but will remain open until alternative provision is available.

The council is currently talking to a registered social landlord about the possibility of creating a purpose-built facility to offer accommodation suitable for people with increasingly complex needs.

Simon Harvey, who set up the action group Save Our Services Newport, which collected a 6,000 names petition against the closure, said the news provided some shortterm relief to families.

Sheila Parsons, whose daughter Katherine Morgan, 38, attends New Willows, added: “We feel now that we are in some sort of dialogue with them in an improved situation but we still feel there’s a long way to go. But at least we feel they are prepared to listen to the needs of the young people and their families.”

Underwood Leisure Centre will shut due to its poor condition and under use, but members agreed to develop activities for youngsters at other buildings in the village.

Cllr Martyn Kellaway, who represents the Underwood ward, said the decision was disappointing. He said closing the centre would still cost the council £30,000 a year in rates and security and residents have instead submitted a business case with plans to make it self-sufficient.

This includes setting up a trust run by 36 volunteers and reopening the bar to make money. He said the council is yet to respond but locals would continue to lobby members.

Councillors also ploughed ahead with plans to withdraw funding to Gwent Music Support Service.

Instead schools will be expected to find money from their own budgets to continue sessions, while the council will create a £15,000 hardship fund to provide financial support for those who cannot afford fees.

The under-threat Maindee Library was saved after members agreed it could stay open, but under reduced opening hours of 36 per week.

The council will also look to use the building for more community-based activities.

Jan Townsend said she was thrilled by the news: “Hallelujah! I’m absolutely delighted. It’s wonderful news, I am so glad.”

The money to continue such services will be paid for with £195,000 from the council’s administration priority budget and a proposed council tax increase.

Council tax bills to increase

COUNCIL tax in Newport is set to rise by 3.5 per cent.

This will see band D taxpayers’ yearly fees rise from £825.98 to £854.89 – up by £28.91 or around 56 pence a week.

Newport residents already pay one of the lowest council taxes in Wales and the whole of the UK.

Cllr Bob Bright, said: “Cabinet has provisionally agreed a rise in council tax for residents. We have to balance the need to make savings with maintaining services and protecting jobs, while at the same time acknowledging that residents are also dealing with the impact of the financial crisis.”

ARGUS COMMENT: Praise for listening

THIS newspaper has criticised Newport City Council’s political leadership for creating a perception it is remote and unwilling to engage.

So it is good to report the council’s consultation on its proposed budget cuts was genuine and we praise the leadership for listening to those people worst affected by its plans. As we have said before, all councils have to make tough decisions and take money away from services they would rather keep running. But at least Newport has shown it is willing to listen to residents and change its plans if it can.

Keeping Maindee Library open, agreeing the current residents of threatened care homes will not have to move if they do not wish to, and providing a hardship fund for school pupils who cannot afford to use the Gwent Music Support Service are all welcome moves.

The vast majority of proposed cuts are still taking place, of course, but at least the bitter pill has been sweetened a little for some people.

The 2013/14 budget year is likely to be the start of several years of financial hardship for councils like Newport.

They will have to make increasingly unpopular decisions as central government’s austerity measures bite hard. We will undoubtedly disagree with some decisions.

But if councils listen to and engage with residents, as Newport has done in this consultation, then there may be some good news to be found amid the bad.

Comments(26)

Harryhedghog says...
11:40am Tue 19 Feb 13

This does not add up, Council wages frozen but an increase by inflation in council tax, this means they actual have more money to spend!. The largest single costs are wages.

Harryhedghog says...
11:40am Tue 19 Feb 13

This does not add up, Council wages frozen but an increase by inflation in council tax, this means they actual have more money to spend!. The largest single costs are wages.

Bobevans says...
1:00pm Tue 19 Feb 13

There are still no efficency savings coming out of Newport Council. All the do is cut services

Reduce the number of Council buildings to cut costs. Reduce the number of staff employed by the council by about 10%

Savings can be made by sharing service something Newpoprt council keeps avoiding

Most councils in Wales new have their own call centres why?. What is wrong with one central call centre for South East Wales?

Why does each council need it's own council tax department. What is wrong with one for South East Wales. Each council can still set its one rate but sending out of bills and handling of payments and general administration can be done centrally

Why does each council need it's own Legal department, own finance department, own HR department , own Supply chain etc


There are big efficiency saving to be made but Newport Councils and the other local council are just not doing it. Preferring instead to cut services and put up council tax

Link the Councils bosses pay to cutting costs. They would soon become more focussed if their pay rise depended on it

Westminster provided funding to enable council tax to be frozen in Wales so their is no real excuse for it going up.

blackandamber says...
1:42pm Tue 19 Feb 13

Why are we still maintaining 50 councillors in Newport in my ward there are approximately 4000 people eligible to vote. Judging by the last crumb of democracy we were thrown to elect a police commissioner at even more expense to the tax payer, not to many bothered to vote so why do we need three councillors to look after so few people. I your'e going to make cuts start at the top. Thirty councillors are more than enough for a town of 140,000 people.

Harryhedghog says...
2:06pm Tue 19 Feb 13

Bobevans wrote:
There are still no efficency savings coming out of Newport Council. All the do is cut services

Reduce the number of Council buildings to cut costs. Reduce the number of staff employed by the council by about 10%

Savings can be made by sharing service something Newpoprt council keeps avoiding

Most councils in Wales new have their own call centres why?. What is wrong with one central call centre for South East Wales?

Why does each council need it's own council tax department. What is wrong with one for South East Wales. Each council can still set its one rate but sending out of bills and handling of payments and general administration can be done centrally

Why does each council need it's own Legal department, own finance department, own HR department , own Supply chain etc


There are big efficiency saving to be made but Newport Councils and the other local council are just not doing it. Preferring instead to cut services and put up council tax

Link the Councils bosses pay to cutting costs. They would soon become more focussed if their pay rise depended on it

Westminster provided funding to enable council tax to be frozen in Wales so their is no real excuse for it going up.
Far to much common sense in this comment for Newport CC

D Taylor says...
3:53pm Tue 19 Feb 13

Harryhedghog wrote:
This does not add up, Council wages frozen but an increase by inflation in council tax, this means they actual have more money to spend!. The largest single costs are wages.
You need to see the whole picture. This is just part of it. You don't know whether grant-aid from the WAG has been reduced. If it has maybe the Council will not have more money contrary to what you suggest. Also a lot of the council tax goes to Gwent Police. The Council have no control over the police budget.

Severn40 says...
4:33pm Tue 19 Feb 13

Not that the Welsh Government has had a generous settlement from Westminster but it should be noted the Welsh Government has not passed on their percentage increase to local councils. So local councils are disproportionately suffering because Carwyn Jones and co fascination with pet projects and schemes.

Having said that, I do believe Councillor Bright and his pals should have approached the budget setting process in a more structured away. This means going back to first basics and looking at what needs to be delivered and what the priorities of Newport people should be. This does mean you have to get a handle on the big ticket items. Otherwise all other services will disproportionately suffer. Sadly, I somehow suspect we will back in the same boat next year.

Crazydad says...
4:42pm Tue 19 Feb 13

This may be controversial but move the council out of the civc centre and other officers aornd Newport. This would reduce the massive running costs. Sell the land for Housing.

Move to purpose built offices (efficient and cost effective) that can accomodate all staff in one location. This would remove the costs of mileage claim (and the admin to process these claims) of travelling between buildings within Newport.

The Civic Centre represents an old and tired Newport, new offices with a rent that has been negotiated to its cheapest price would demonstrate that Newports is and wants to look to the future.

Serpent_terror says...
5:20pm Tue 19 Feb 13

blackandamber wrote:
Why are we still maintaining 50 councillors in Newport in my ward there are approximately 4000 people eligible to vote. Judging by the last crumb of democracy we were thrown to elect a police commissioner at even more expense to the tax payer, not to many bothered to vote so why do we need three councillors to look after so few people. I your'e going to make cuts start at the top. Thirty councillors are more than enough for a town of 140,000 people.
I totally agree why do we need all these Councillors we have three on this estate WHY? one could be enough I don't see the council making cuts at Councillors level's or maybe a good idea is to make these Councillors do as volunteer's really working for there communities.
The money saved may save more services or even why don't they take a pay cut? I am ashamed of this council and the one before it.

siameselady says...
5:21pm Tue 19 Feb 13

blackandamber wrote:
Why are we still maintaining 50 councillors in Newport in my ward there are approximately 4000 people eligible to vote. Judging by the last crumb of democracy we were thrown to elect a police commissioner at even more expense to the tax payer, not to many bothered to vote so why do we need three councillors to look after so few people. I your'e going to make cuts start at the top. Thirty councillors are more than enough for a town of 140,000 people.
I agree!

Independentvoter says...
6:34pm Tue 19 Feb 13

The people of Underwood will not be praising the leadership of this council for listening to their concerns neither will the residents of hillside etc. Choosing to save a library over a nursing home ?

How many signatures does it take to demand a By-election for the people of Newport ?

Independentvoter says...
6:50pm Tue 19 Feb 13

What about using this grand Civic Centre to make some revenue by turning it into a museum art gallery, or even a Tate Newport ?

The council's own words ' we need to make cuts in these financial times'. So they won't mind moving to a less grandeous buliding for their part-time meetings will they.

One question though for the Argus Team.

Can a member of the public gain full wheelchair access to the public seating area in the civic Centre ?

Answer.... NO.

Illegal.....YES

Just a thought !

Ranger12 says...
7:22pm Tue 19 Feb 13

Bobevans wrote:
There are still no efficency savings coming out of Newport Council. All the do is cut services

Reduce the number of Council buildings to cut costs. Reduce the number of staff employed by the council by about 10%

Savings can be made by sharing service something Newpoprt council keeps avoiding

Most councils in Wales new have their own call centres why?. What is wrong with one central call centre for South East Wales?

Why does each council need it's own council tax department. What is wrong with one for South East Wales. Each council can still set its one rate but sending out of bills and handling of payments and general administration can be done centrally

Why does each council need it's own Legal department, own finance department, own HR department , own Supply chain etc


There are big efficiency saving to be made but Newport Councils and the other local council are just not doing it. Preferring instead to cut services and put up council tax

Link the Councils bosses pay to cutting costs. They would soon become more focussed if their pay rise depended on it

Westminster provided funding to enable council tax to be frozen in Wales so their is no real excuse for it going up.
Excellent post and thoughts but to get the council to modernise and embrace what the private sector have done for years as the wealth creators of the country is potentially a lost cause.
It would be interesting to see the budget for council expenses and wage / allowance costs maybe the Argos can make a freedom of information request.

DavidMclean says...
8:02pm Tue 19 Feb 13

A £7m shortfall? So nearly one third of the cost of that useless white elephant which is the new railway station building. The know the one - it has a leaking roof, is cold and characterless, doesn't function as it should, yet some idiots at the council probably pat themselves on the back at how clever they were to sign it off, while some developer ran off laughing into the distance with his pockets stuffed with OUR money!

Rossykins says...
9:33pm Tue 19 Feb 13

I think the Council need an independent time and motion study carried out. If the findings were to indicate that savings could be made by implementing redundancies in those sectors not achieving their targets this would save money. After cutbacks in social care, hospitals and housing have been made there will be nothing more left to cut, except of course the vast salaries of the Council's officers.

Stott4691 says...
9:35pm Tue 19 Feb 13

David McLean,I think you,ll find that the railway station was paid for by Network rail,despite popular belief the Council aren,t responsible for everything in the city

47alan47 says...
9:27am Wed 20 Feb 13

So it looks like everyone is happy with council tax going up by 3.5% then.

moogieenglish@hotmail.co.uk says...
9:57am Wed 20 Feb 13

Newport you are a laughing stock , you have destroyed this once great town...all decisions you have made have dragged us down even more...How much did that planning debacle cost us ...can I put a big sign on my home....How much is it costing to put the bus station back where it started . Do you know it is embarrassing when people get off a coach looking for a toilet and they are all shut , this is a city with the facilities of a third world country...You really believe putting a Debenhams here will help, even the charity shops cant make money now ..You want to put Newport back on its feet BRING THE SUPERSTORES BACK ...lower your business rates ...CLEAN THE PLACE UP

blackandamber says...
10:51am Wed 20 Feb 13

blackandamber wrote:
Why are we still maintaining 50 councillors in Newport in my ward there are approximately 4000 people eligible to vote. Judging by the last crumb of democracy we were thrown to elect a police commissioner at even more expense to the tax payer, not to many bothered to vote so why do we need three councillors to look after so few people. I your'e going to make cuts start at the top. Thirty councillors are more than enough for a town of 140,000 people.
Iv'e just changed my opinion Newport is not so bad off after all. You could live in Blaenau Gwent they have the burden of 42 councillors to look after the needs of 69000 thousand people. It will be no surprise that 33 councillors are good ole boy, I feel your pain socialists who now want to increase the council tax by 4.6%
And I'll bet they still vote for them next election.

Independentvoter says...
1:08pm Wed 20 Feb 13

Why not google how to become an Independent councillor.

We need candidates to fight every ward then we wont have to vote 'them' back in.

Do any serving councillors face Argus posters on here ?

blackandamber says...
1:32pm Wed 20 Feb 13

Independentvoter wrote:
Why not google how to become an Independent councillor.

We need candidates to fight every ward then we wont have to vote 'them' back in.

Do any serving councillors face Argus posters on here ?
I know how to become a councillor it's just that time is not on my side as I'm nearer the exit than the entrance.
If I was younger I would and do the job for nothing. But I do wonder how a local council has become so politicised, rather than trying to make a difference to their city, without being hamstrung by political dogma.

Ranger12 says...
9:48pm Wed 20 Feb 13

blackandamber wrote:
blackandamber wrote:
Why are we still maintaining 50 councillors in Newport in my ward there are approximately 4000 people eligible to vote. Judging by the last crumb of democracy we were thrown to elect a police commissioner at even more expense to the tax payer, not to many bothered to vote so why do we need three councillors to look after so few people. I your'e going to make cuts start at the top. Thirty councillors are more than enough for a town of 140,000 people.
Iv'e just changed my opinion Newport is not so bad off after all. You could live in Blaenau Gwent they have the burden of 42 councillors to look after the needs of 69000 thousand people. It will be no surprise that 33 councillors are good ole boy, I feel your pain socialists who now want to increase the council tax by 4.6%
And I'll bet they still vote for them next election.
There appears to be a correlation between the number of councillors and how economically struggling an area is. More councillors = more struggle or is it just more labour councillors

Bobevans says...
12:31pm Thu 21 Feb 13

The problem remains that Newport Council just cuts services rather than improve efficiency. What that means is that each year we have the same number of council staff providing fewer services so efficiency goes down and costs go up

wizurd says...
9:42pm Sun 24 Feb 13

nice lot of ignorant people commenting i see. how about you do the freedom of information requests and actually find out the facts. Newport has made plenty of staff cuts and as for closing the civic centre... really?? can u imagine how much it would cost a developer to knock all that down and then build houses on. It wouldn't be worth the money. But like i said actually do some research, the council has been closing lots of offices and buildings outside of the civic and moving staff into the centre in order to cut rental costs and then sell what buildings they can to generate revenue. So basically they are doing what your asking, cutting staff and saving money on buildings. As for centralising services. Already being done as far as i'm aware but lets not forget its not quite as simple as just that and as for outsourcing... that would be a massive waste of money. In very few cases does it ever actually save money over the long term. Councillor numbers however is a good idea. I'd say most councils could do with losing a lot more councillors. It is a drain and less are needed thats for sure.

foxy3rd says...
10:16pm Mon 25 Feb 13

If the council don't have enough money to make ends meet why do they keep wasting funds on the tarmac substitute that they keep using on Wharf Rd.It is not hard wearing enough for a road with that amount of traffic.and needs replacing every year at a ridiculous cost to the taxpayer.How can the council justify it.They keep saying that they have to make cuts to save money, but they consistently waste money doing stupid things like this and taking out the perfectly good seating along Commercial and replacing them with all that less comfortable seating where is the common sense in it all ?

scraptheWAG says...
6:50am Fri 1 Mar 13

cuts to services yet the huge bureaucracy that is the WAG continues at a huge pace now costing nearly HALF A BILLION pounds a year to run 200 million p.a to spend on welsh language but closing of libraries and other front line services.

And yet the stupid and the idle still vote for their precious labour.

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree