WEEKENDER: A longer school day must be all about the children

WEEKENDER: A longer school day must be all about the children

Chemistry Teacher with Students in Class (3739886)

Argus-Mark 02-02-13 Wales v Ireland Toby Faletau holds off Cian Healy (3740129)

First published in News

IT is awfully decent of the Prime Minister’s former policv chief Paul Kirby to volunteer for the role as the UK’s number one hate figure among children and young people.

Up and down the land, harassed parents battling their moody teenagers over homework, and trying to put feisty six-year-olds to bed early, because they have to go to school in the morning, can now deflect their kids’ ire simply by saying:

“You think I’m horrible? Just wait until you hear what Paul Kirby has got in store for you!”

This statement will be met with one of two responses, depending on the age of the errant child.

Younger ones will merely ask: “Mummy/daddy, who’s Paul the Furby?” Teenagers will shrug, make a face like they have bitten into a chilli pepper, and mumble something along the lines of “uh?”

Then you will be able to inform them through a satisfied smile that the nice Mr Kirby is proposing that they all be made to stay at school for nine hours a day.

The younger ones will not really understand the implications of this. They will probably just think that Paul is an odd name to call a Furby

But the teenagers will be outraged and project their disgust and disagreement with – and hatred of – Paul Kirby onto you.

Doors may be slammed. Music may be turned up loud(er). Friends may be texted furiously with the news – “Omigod, I don’ belieeeve i’, d’you!?!”

“Nah, ‘s no’rappnin’, ri’? ‘m norravvin ‘at, ‘s ou’rageous.”

Or mangled words to that effect.

But wait kids, there’s more. Nasty Mr Kirby is also proposing that school holidays be cut from 13 weeks a year to just seven.

Cue more angst.

Seriously though, while this is a proposal aimed specifically at England, its implications for education across the rest of the UK if it comes to pass cannot be ignored. And, while nine hours is a bit steep, the idea of a longer school day has its merits.

For instance, crowded school timetables can make it increasingly difficult to provide pupils – especially those going into Key Stage Three - with many choices concerning the subjects they are able to study, due in no small part to the introduction of vocational courses alongside academic studies.

Too many children have to drop too early what they and their parents see as fundamental subjects, due to the accommodation of more vocational subjects.

An increase in the length of the school day would of course have to be backed by billions of pounds of investment, but assume that were a given. Then there would be more time for lessons and therefore in principle the capacity for a greater choice of subjects.

Some might like the idea of a reduction in school holidays, but that may be down to making things easier for them, rather than being regarded as a boost to children’s education.

And that is where I have reservations over Mr Kirby’s radical vision.

Much of the commentary in favour of the proposal this week has focused as much if not more on the wider benefits to 'society' rather than to children: The increased capacity for parents, mainly of course, mums, to go (back) to work, or work longer hours than they are currently able; an increase in economic growth and tax-take due to the former; a big reduction in child care costs; keeping children off the streets in the late afternoon/early evening, when youth crime apparently peaks.

All laudable stuff, but this really should be all about the benefits to children. Of course, there may be spin-off advantages, but the educational positives should be what the debate focuses on.

Some commentators have likened a longer school day to the stealing of childhoods. That is extreme, but were the idea to be pursued - in England, Wales, Scotland, Northern Ireland, or combinations of these - a balance would have to be struck.

Education is vital but, like adults need time away from work, children need time away from the classroom.

Comments (1)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

5:59pm Sat 1 Feb 14

pbhj says...

Kids aren't going to school so they can start their lives at a later date - they're already living. Adulthood is already bleak enough with the requirement for most to spend 5 or more days a week working 8 or more hours we don't need to ruin childhood as well.

It's not just the limited experience that school affords but also the lack of family contact which IMO leaves society weaker and feeds in to further weakening of the social structure in future generations as people lose sight of how to behave when they're free from the authoritarian oversight of a school (or state) dictating their every move.

School can be a lifeless and dull experience for many (and a joyful and vibrant one for many others too, yes) it seems overly harsh to subject such children to further confinement.

If it's about greater choice and wider educational experience then the government could provide vouchers for out-of-school clubs or family trips.
Kids aren't going to school so they can start their lives at a later date - they're already living. Adulthood is already bleak enough with the requirement for most to spend 5 or more days a week working 8 or more hours we don't need to ruin childhood as well. It's not just the limited experience that school affords but also the lack of family contact which IMO leaves society weaker and feeds in to further weakening of the social structure in future generations as people lose sight of how to behave when they're free from the authoritarian oversight of a school (or state) dictating their every move. School can be a lifeless and dull experience for many (and a joyful and vibrant one for many others too, yes) it seems overly harsh to subject such children to further confinement. If it's about greater choice and wider educational experience then the government could provide vouchers for out-of-school clubs or family trips. pbhj
  • Score: 5

Comments are closed on this article.

Send us your news, pictures and videos

Most read stories

Local Info

Enter your postcode, town or place name

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree