Probe launched over Valleys AM's racetrack row

PROBE LAUNCHED: Blaenau Gwent AM and minister Alun Davies

PROBE LAUNCHED: Blaenau Gwent AM and minister Alun Davies

First published in News
Last updated

AMID a brewing row over the Circuit of Wales the first minister has asked the head of the Welsh Government's civil service to conduct a probe into whether the actions of Alun Davies as a constituency AM has conflicted with his position as a minister.

A storm has broken out over whether the Blaenau Gwent AM, who is also natural resources minister, has broken the ministerial code over the Circuit of Wales project after it emerged that he had contacted Natural Resources Wales in favour of the project.

NRW had been objecting to the £280 million racetrack but later dropped its concerns in the months following Mr Davies’ correspondence.

Members of the opposition had demanded an investigation into whether the code that ministers are expected to abide by was broken – and the leader of the Tories has suggested that if a breach is found Mr Davies should step down.

Carwyn Jones, first minister, said this morning that the permanent secretary Sir Derek Jones has been asked to look into the facts surrounding the issue, and to report back in two weeks.

He said: “There has been concern expressed recently about the actions of one of my ministers and whether his role as a constituency member has conflicted with his position as a Minister.

“In light of this, I have today asked the permanent secretary to look into the facts surrounding this matter.

“I have requested that the permanent secretary reports back to me within two weeks. I will update members in due course.”

This morning Tory leader of the opposition Andrew RT Davies told a press conference: “If on investigation I found the breach had occurred then I would expect the minister to go. Simple as that.”

Kirsty Williams, Welsh Lib Dem leader, told her Tuesday morning briefing: “I think given the chain of events of Natural Resources Wales expressing grave concerns about the environmental impact of that particular project, and then receives a letter from the minister responsible for them and their remit letter, and then subsequently all their concerns about their environmental impact of that project go away, it’s going to make people suspicious.”

Llyr Gruffydd AM, of Plaid, told journalists: “If rules have been broken clearly he [Alun Davies] will be aware there will be implications from that.

“The normal course of action is that you raise issues with the planning authority because it’s their decision. It’s very strange that you go to one of the statutory consultees because there are a number of them, particularly not when you preside over that organisation as minister.

“For him not to realise that raises questions about his judgement as well."

Mr Gruffydd said he doesn’t want to call for someone’s resignation before “we know the facts".“If you don’t play to the rules you shouldn’t be allowed to play.”

Asked about the decision by the Welsh Government not to call the planning application in, Mr Gruffydd said: “If any potential subsequent inquiry shows that there was undue influence and that advice was changed as a result of that it of course brings into question the validity of the original decision.”

He said the issue leaves the application opens to judicial review: “As things stands he could become one of the biggest Achilles heels of the project.”

Mr Gruffydd had asked Carwyn Jones in the Assembly on October 8 to confirm whether it would not be appropriate for officials or members of the Welsh Government to influence Natural Resources Wales when it comes to giving opinions on planning applications.

Mr Jones responded: “Yes, I can. Natural Resources Wales is a body that is independent of Government.”

Comments (6)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

2:26pm Tue 10 Jun 14

Good Job No Kids says...

Either way, the environmental impacts are not substantial enough to warrant denying this area of some investment. It certainly needs it and doesn't get it anywhere near often enough. The odd bird or mouse is quite insignificant when compared to long term unemployed getting opportunities to work.
Either way, the environmental impacts are not substantial enough to warrant denying this area of some investment. It certainly needs it and doesn't get it anywhere near often enough. The odd bird or mouse is quite insignificant when compared to long term unemployed getting opportunities to work. Good Job No Kids
  • Score: -4

5:44pm Tue 10 Jun 14

Julesblaina1 says...

Could our useless AM finally put the mockers on the circuit of wales, what was he thinking, he must have realised he could not intervene as he was the boss of Natural Resources Wales. What a plonker, have to remember this next year when he wants our votes.
Could our useless AM finally put the mockers on the circuit of wales, what was he thinking, he must have realised he could not intervene as he was the boss of Natural Resources Wales. What a plonker, have to remember this next year when he wants our votes. Julesblaina1
  • Score: 9

7:32pm Tue 10 Jun 14

kez1968 says...

Julesblaina1 wrote:
Could our useless AM finally put the mockers on the circuit of wales, what was he thinking, he must have realised he could not intervene as he was the boss of Natural Resources Wales. What a plonker, have to remember this next year when he wants our votes.
definately useless, just like the rest of the useless buggers in blaenau gwent, yet they are all labour, so they will still get in, **** shame we dont live in a marginal, might get some decent politicians around here.
[quote][p][bold]Julesblaina1[/bold] wrote: Could our useless AM finally put the mockers on the circuit of wales, what was he thinking, he must have realised he could not intervene as he was the boss of Natural Resources Wales. What a plonker, have to remember this next year when he wants our votes.[/p][/quote]definately useless, just like the rest of the useless buggers in blaenau gwent, yet they are all labour, so they will still get in, **** shame we dont live in a marginal, might get some decent politicians around here. kez1968
  • Score: 1

8:09pm Tue 10 Jun 14

Julesblaina1 says...

kez1968 wrote:
Julesblaina1 wrote:
Could our useless AM finally put the mockers on the circuit of wales, what was he thinking, he must have realised he could not intervene as he was the boss of Natural Resources Wales. What a plonker, have to remember this next year when he wants our votes.
definately useless, just like the rest of the useless buggers in blaenau gwent, yet they are all labour, so they will still get in, **** shame we dont live in a marginal, might get some decent politicians around here.
independent got in before them the same can happen again, just need more people to stand as independent councillors
[quote][p][bold]kez1968[/bold] wrote: [quote][p][bold]Julesblaina1[/bold] wrote: Could our useless AM finally put the mockers on the circuit of wales, what was he thinking, he must have realised he could not intervene as he was the boss of Natural Resources Wales. What a plonker, have to remember this next year when he wants our votes.[/p][/quote]definately useless, just like the rest of the useless buggers in blaenau gwent, yet they are all labour, so they will still get in, **** shame we dont live in a marginal, might get some decent politicians around here.[/p][/quote]independent got in before them the same can happen again, just need more people to stand as independent councillors Julesblaina1
  • Score: 4

10:20am Wed 11 Jun 14

Severn40 says...

At the end of the day, the fate of Alun Davies will be decided by...Carwyn Jones. Wales is the only place when the responsibility of the Ministerial code rests with the leader. Expect a small ticking off and then...carry on regardless.
At the end of the day, the fate of Alun Davies will be decided by...Carwyn Jones. Wales is the only place when the responsibility of the Ministerial code rests with the leader. Expect a small ticking off and then...carry on regardless. Severn40
  • Score: 2

5:52pm Thu 12 Jun 14

varteg1 says...

“The normal course of action is that you raise issues with the planning authority because it’s their decision. said Llyr Gruffydd




would that also apply to the Assembly appointing an independent inspector to formulate an inquiry....then a minister dismissing the findings and result of that inquiry, because it was not wanted by one of his mates.

More or less like having someone tried for murder, by a court which sentences him to life, which is set aside by the minister because he was a mate.

Maybe Carl Sargent can answer that?
“The normal course of action is that you raise issues with the planning authority because it’s their decision. said Llyr Gruffydd would that also apply to the Assembly appointing an independent inspector to formulate an inquiry....then a minister dismissing the findings and result of that inquiry, because it was not wanted by one of his mates. More or less like having someone tried for murder, by a court which sentences him to life, which is set aside by the minister because he was a mate. Maybe Carl Sargent can answer that? varteg1
  • Score: 0

Comments are closed on this article.

Send us your news, pictures and videos

Most read stories

Local Info

Enter your postcode, town or place name

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree