News RSS Feed


Why I'm quitting Plaid for the Tories


GWENT Assembly member Mohammad Asghar last night defended his decision to defect from Plaid Cymru to the Conservatives.

The 64-year-old AM for South Wales East, who lives in Newport and became the first Assembly Member from an ethnic minority when he was elected in May 2007, said he was joining the Tories because he felt “out of tune” with the views of Plaid Cymru.

The opponent of full Welsh independence told the Argus he had joined Plaid in 2000 as a way of getting into the 'political system' - with the hope he could change the party's policies from the inside.

But yesterday, amid allegations from political opponents that he had 'jumped before he was pushed' to make way for Plaid MP Adam Price's goal of joining the Senedd as a list AM, the Pakistan-born politician said he had failed.

He said he was “a little parrot in a jungle."

"Unity is strength and we should be pulling together," he said, claiming full independence would be disastrous for Wales.

"I felt the Conservatives were the party to offer the best future for the whole of Britain, not just one part of it."

There are also strong republican elements in Plaid Cymru, a polar opposite to the view of ardent royalist Mr Asghar, who was member of the Conservative party for a short time more than 20 years ago.

Fellow Conservative AM William Graham said he had always felt 'perplexed' that Mr Asghar, a former Newport councillor, had joined Plaid in 2000.

Mr Asghar's 26-year-old daughter Natasha, who has stood as a Plaid candidate in previous Assembly and European elections, has also defected to the Tories.

She said: “For me, family is everything. I believe in my father. Wherever he goes I will follow.’’ Last night, after sitting in the Conservative benches in the Senedd for the first time, Mr Asghar said he was looking forward to meeting Tory leader David Cameron, and refused to rule out the possibility of standing in the forthcoming General Election as a Conservative candidate.

He said he would be with the Tories 'for life'.

But he showed no bitterness to his former party, describing leader Ieuan Wyn Jones as a 'thorough gentleman'.

Mr Wyn Jones said he was disappointed, and chairman of the Plaid Cymru group, Dai Lloyd called on him to resign his seat, claiming he had no mandate to sit as a Tory.

Mr Asghar said he would not be standing down and would still represent the people of South Wales East.

Plaid now have 14 AMs and the Tories 13.


Your Say YourGwent

Gareth, Newport says...
10:38am Wed 9 Dec 09

The best comment about this debacle is on Paul Flynn's blog today. I think it says it all.

yesme, cwmbran says...
11:14am Wed 9 Dec 09

To quote one of his one-liners.
"Vote Plaid Cymru the Party of Wales "
GWENT Assembly member Mohammad Asghar is a Hypocrite.

yesme, cwmbran says...
11:24am Wed 9 Dec 09

To quote Paul Flynn "West LibDems are livid tonight. They are the only party that Mohammad Ashgar has not joined'.
http://paulflynnmp.t
ypepad.com/

Saes, Blaenau Gwent says...
12:12pm Wed 9 Dec 09

Plaid Cymru wants an independent Wales? Who knew? Clearly not Mr Asghar; what a fine on-the ball politician he makes.

JoePM, says...
1:30pm Wed 9 Dec 09

If people have contempt for politicians then stories like this justify that contempt. Mr Ashgar has already been a Tory and Labour, joins Plaid Cymru (without supporting Welsh nationalism or independence?!) then reckons he might be better off back with the Tories. The local people must love that decision!

The people who voted Plaid Cymru would not have supported Ashgar the Conservative. He should resign and be replaced by the next Plaid Cymru candidate on the list.

It shows the Conservatives lack of political judgement that they are prepared to tolerate this carpetbagger.

D-G, Newport says...
1:36pm Wed 9 Dec 09

She said: “For me, family is everything. I believe in my father. Wherever he goes I will follow.’’

That's a cute sentiment coming from a child, but a bit disconcerting from a full-grown adult woman.

Radio Wales, Newport says...
2:08pm Wed 9 Dec 09

Don't criticise, just hear his own words.
He wasn't good enough to be elected as a Tory so he crept in as a PC-who-wasn't to pander his own ambitions.
Would I trust him to represent me? I'd rather not! He might be a communist next year.

Salem, Blackwood says...
2:46pm Wed 9 Dec 09

They all Play MUSICAL CHAIRS to keep Their Noses Firmly Planted in the Taxpayers Funded Gravy Train Trough..No PRINCIPLES No MORALS in British Politics anymore..A Plague on ALL THEIR HOUSES!!!!!!

diandai, new inn says...
4:20pm Wed 9 Dec 09

this guy is a complete hypocrite and turncoat to boot. how can he be trusted when it appears that even he doe's not know where his allegiances lie.may the fleas of a thousand afghan camels nest in his nether regions.

islwyn09, Abercarn says...
5:53pm Wed 9 Dec 09

Cant argue with that Salem!His excuse that Adam Price would replace him is completely false!He will stand for a West Wales constituency close to where he is an MP @ present!Mind you I wouldnt say no to him becoming AM for Islwyn to replace the lazy mare we've had "representing"us for last 8 years!

independent voter, newport says...
7:08pm Wed 9 Dec 09

Correct me if im wrong but wasnt it in 1950 when the conservatives last had an Asian candidate in Newport (Pill) and he lost. Isnt it also ironic that the son of a Tory MP set up the BNP sorry but you will have to work that one out yourselves - the tories have lost me !!! so what do they actually stand for now ? everyone and everything ?????????

islwyn09, Abercarn says...
9:06pm Wed 9 Dec 09

Sssssssshhhhhhhhhhhh
hhhhhhhhh!Independan
t Voter thats a state secret!Lmao!Its almost as ironic as a jew joining the nazi party in Hitler's Germany!His action have done nothing for the reputation of asian politicians!Again I ask him,how would he have voted in India 60yrs ago when Pakistan was created?

westender, newbridge says...
10:40pm Sat 12 Dec 09

GOSH what a lot of questions, some answers now please

independent voter, newport says...
8:15am Sun 13 Dec 09

Mohammed Asghar wants to be like the hard working Conservative William Graham who works 40 hours a week at his Estate Agents - He works 40 hours a week as a Newport City Councillor - He works 40 hours a week as a JP - He works 40 hours a week as a Welsh Assembly member - WOW 160 hours a week - Isnt that illegal under European Law - He is also a father of three - WHAT GREED - Then you have The conservative ('2homes David Davies' for Monmouth) - A Local Councillor 40hrs a week - an Assembly Member 40hrs a week a Member of Parliament 40hrs a week all with expenses of course. Asghars joining the Tory Gravy Train all aboard as they pull into the new train station that looks like a telephone reciever whoop whoop

independent voter, newport says...
8:24am Sun 13 Dec 09

Forgot to add David Davies MP-AM-Councillor for monmouth the son of Peter Davies Newport Councillor stated that he was the most prominant Right Wing MP - AM in Wales - Ive got the printed article if Mr Asghar would like to view it. He wont stay long in that Party - Nobody does hahaha

islwyn09, Abercarn says...
12:10am Tue 15 Dec 09

Only person who can answer them Westender is Asghar himself!But all you'll get out of him is a tirade of lies!This guy has just become the poster boy for all those who feel that all politicians are there for themselves!How can he look @ himself in the mirror in the morning knowing that he has conned & cheated thousands of voters by changing horses mid race!

Comments are closed on this article.

aa-mo.jpg Mohammad Asghar

Local Advertisers

Local Information

Enter your postcode, town or place name

House prices »   Schools »   Crime »   Hospitals »