Report this comment
  • "Mr Ward,

    I am, as you expect, diametrically opposed to your published opinion that these elections are unwanted, unnecessary or a real waste of public money.

    They are a move to infuse the accountable voice and wishes of local people, through democratic means, directly into the heart of the decision makers and thence the actions of their police force.

    I am, however, a very great supporter of your opinion and ability to make it.

    I say this, as as Independent Candidate, I am so glad you are a realist in relation to the vote for a political candidate is a recipe for the police to be run on political dogma and Westminster or Senedd based edicts.

    Recent local elections were 'won' on the submission that a vote away from Conservatives is a vote to give 'Cameron and his cronies a bloody nose'. It has not happened!

    The people of Gwent and its valleys have a rich heritage of being able to see the wood for the trees and supporting Independent candidates from their area to get their democratic voice heard.

    As I said - I think the Police and Crime Commissioner elections are another step forward for the electorate of Gwent.

    I must admit that their cost can be argued but remember that it was Nick Clegg and his political allies that prevented these elections taking place alongside the council elections in May this year.

    The incoming Police and Crime Commissioner, this November, will be the only to be elected in this month. Their first term in office is not four years ... It is until May 2016 when the Police and Crime Commissioner elections will be held at the same time as the local council elections.

    So ... in May 2016 ... either the elections are free or the council and P&CC elections will be half the cost they are today.

    Democracy costs money and in this case has to start somewhere.

    I ask that we at least embrace the progression of democracy and give this post a chance

    Most sincerely,

    Christopher Edwin Wright

  • This field is mandatory
  • This field is mandatory
  • Please note we will not accept reports with HTML tags or URLs in them.

  • Enter the above word in the box below

THE EDITOR'S CHAIR: Elections for Police Commissioner are pointless

ELECTION: Police on patrol – but will the creation of a Police and Crime Commissioner for Gwent be of any benefit in the battle against crime

ELECTION: Police on patrol – but will the creation of a Police and Crime Commissioner for Gwent be of any benefit in the battle against crime

First published in Editor's Chair South Wales Argus: NEW EDITOR: Kevin Ward by

HAS there ever been a more pointless set of elections than the ones facing the electorate in November?

If you didn’t know (and it’s no badge of shame to be ignorant of this) on November 15 we get to vote for Gwent’s first Police and Crime Commissioner.

All other police force areas across England and Wales will also be electing PCCs.

So who will you be choosing between if (and it’s a big ‘if’ as these elections are likely to result in incredibly low turnouts) you decide to cast your vote?

Well, with the exception of a few independents they are likely to be politicians, as most of the main parties are fielding candidates.

And in my experience, putting politicians in charge of anything is never a good idea.

What powers will a PCC have? They’ll set the force budget and precept (the percentage of your council tax that pays for the police) and they’ll set a police and crime plan and hold the chief constable to account for delivering it.

Most worrying of all, they’ll have the power to hire and fire the chief constable.

Despite PCCs having to swear an oath of impartiality, we run the risk of having police forces run by political dogma rather than public need.

PCCs are the brainchild of the Tories, although the government has seemed utterly uninterested in the idea since coming to power.

Supporters of these elections (and I haven’t met many of them) say they are needed because current police authorities are unaccountable and if you took a photograph of a local police authority chairman into the street most people would not know who they are.

So there we have it. Millions will be spent at a time of austerity on elections that hardly anyone seems to know about or want because the people currently running our police forces aren’t famous enough.

There won’t be a U-turn on these elections, however, and we’ll cover them as we do with all elections – fairly and impartially, explaining the issues and the positions of all candidates to our readers.

But I can’t believe that having a Police and Crime Commissioner is a major priority for most ordinary people.

It’s a pointless political wheeze.

And we will all be paying for it.

No boxing clever with breakfast

LIFE as an editor is not all glamour, you know.

I spent the first three days of this week in Oxford on a company digital media training course.

Please try to contain your excitement.

There’s no five-star luxury for these events. It took place at the offices of the Oxford Mail and I stayed in a Travelodge. In a motorway services area.

Even better than the picturesque setting were the breakfast arrangements.

At check-in the receptionist cheerily reminded me I had booked breakfast for my two-night stay.

Then came the killer line – would I like my breakfasts (yes, both of them) now? Pardon? It was 5.30pm. Breakfast, it turns out, came in a box containing what may well have been orange juice, a bowl containing both cornflakes and milk, a croissant and a muffin.

That’s in a box and handed to guests several hours in advance of actual breakfast time.


Torch team runs into the hundreds

THE other highlight of my Travelodge stay was that it was the sleepover point for the Olympic torch relay support teams as the relay went through Oxfordshire.

There are literally hundreds of these people, all in their branded outfits with branded suitcases and cars.

But I’m sure it’s all fantastic value for money.

Comments (6)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

Comments are closed on this article.

Send us your news, pictures and videos

Most read stories

Local Info

Enter your postcode, town or place name

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree