Ebbw Vale woman supervising convicted criminal was 'seduced' by him into car fraud

South Wales Argus: Woman supervising ex-con 'seduced' into car fraud Woman supervising ex-con 'seduced' into car fraud

A VALLEYS woman in charge of supervising convicted criminals on unpaid work was “seduced” by one of her charges to commit fraud on his behalf, a court heard.

Julia Nash, 47, of Brynhyfryd, Ebbw Vale, “fell under the thrall” of Phillip Coates in 2011, entering a sexual relationship with him, Michael Hammett, prosecuting, told Cardiff Crown Court yesterday.

She bought several cars paid for on credit which she let Coates take, the court heard.

But she falsely incriminated her ex-husband, telling police he had stolen one of the cars when he was entirely innocent.

Nash, who was responsible for supervising convicts, purchased a VW Golf in March 2012 subject to a finance agreement, Mr Hammett told the court, but Coates took the vehicle and sold it on.

A similar incident happened with another vehicle and then again when Nash signed a finance agreement for a £22,000 BMW.

She allowed Coates to use the car, which then went missing, the court heard.

Instead of reporting the matter, Nash maintained the finance agreement for four months, the court heard.

Mr Hammett said: “Having given him three vehicles which went missing, she must have realised what was going on.”

Nash then bought a Vauxhall Corsa for £9,000 which she allowed Coates to drive away the very same day as she collected it.

“The defendant had agreed to be bound by the terms of the finance agreement when it was her intention all along that Coates would steal the vehicle,” Mr Hammett said.

The fraud and Coates’ theft of cars came to £17,500 in total.

Hugh Wallace, defending, said Nash had seen no personal financial benefit from the fraud and had in fact lost “a great deal of money”.

The court heard that in a police interview Coates said: “I thought she had a wicked credit rating. I seen a weakness and I took advantage.

She’s scared of me. I made her think I could get her sacked, [mess] her life up.”

Nash admitted two counts of fraud and one count of perverting the course of justice. The court heard Coates has already been sentenced for his involvement in the crimes.

Recorder of Cardiff Eleri Rees said the consequences Nash had already faced were “disastrous”, including losing her job and seeing her children move to Canada to live with their father, and it was therefore unnecessary to impose an immediate jail term.

She said: “You allowed yourself to become seduced into a relationship with a man who it has to be said is extremely dishonest.

“Coates himself accepted he may have applied pressure and made threats both physical and of a kind undermining your job.

“You are an intelligent woman and if you had stepped back for a moment you should have been able to appreciate you were becoming embroiled in very serious criminal activity.”

She imposed a 12 month suspended prison sentence and a 12 month supervision order.

Comments (5)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

5:22pm Fri 18 Apr 14

Abertillery29 says...

Here we go again - another suspended sentence for a number of criminal acts. She knew exactly what she was doing when she carried out the second offence but kept going. Judges must imprison these people and the persons who employ them must have more safeguards in place to stop them 'falling' for criminals.
Here we go again - another suspended sentence for a number of criminal acts. She knew exactly what she was doing when she carried out the second offence but kept going. Judges must imprison these people and the persons who employ them must have more safeguards in place to stop them 'falling' for criminals. Abertillery29
  • Score: 8

6:12pm Fri 18 Apr 14

jollyjules says...

could not agree more,Abertillery 29,i got conned out of £16,000 and the justice system did nothing,its run rule for one and one for another
could not agree more,Abertillery 29,i got conned out of £16,000 and the justice system did nothing,its run rule for one and one for another jollyjules
  • Score: 7

7:28pm Fri 18 Apr 14

Templar05 says...

I guess she was that blind, that she didn't see that there are single ,good men available ?
I guess she was that blind, that she didn't see that there are single ,good men available ? Templar05
  • Score: 5

10:19am Sat 19 Apr 14

Sally121 says...

The report states the judge said 'her children have moved to Canada so there is no need to impose a jail sentence'. But surely, because of this he could impose an immediate sentence?.
The report states the judge said 'her children have moved to Canada so there is no need to impose a jail sentence'. But surely, because of this he could impose an immediate sentence?. Sally121
  • Score: 7

11:47am Sat 19 Apr 14

displayed says...

A VALLEYS woman in charge of supervising convicted criminals on unpaid work was “seduced” by one of her charges....

How do these people get these high position jobs.
What wally, I mean feel-good official, decided to hire someone with such low self esteem of themselves.

She couldnt supervise a cornflakes packet!

She even tried to implicate her ex into the scheme, she mustav really ated im!
A VALLEYS woman in charge of supervising convicted criminals on unpaid work was “seduced” by one of her charges.... How do these people get these high position jobs. What wally, I mean feel-good official, decided to hire someone with such low self esteem of themselves. She couldnt supervise a cornflakes packet! She even tried to implicate her ex into the scheme, she mustav really ated im! displayed
  • Score: 4

Comments are closed on this article.

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree