Surprised by factual errors

I FIND it interesting that two of the candidates for police commissioner are at a “handbags at dawn” scenario.

Both are former police officers, one a quite senior officer. Both in my opinion should have been absolutely certain of their facts before going public with challengeable statements. Both have let their guard slip and given their previous disciplines, I am surprised they both made serious incorrect statements about candidates wishing to be a police commissioner. If both had researched in a proper manner they would not have erred. A candidate for that position should not have left themselves wide open to criticism in my view. My own opinion on this position is that while all are indicating independence, how can someone with numerous years in the police discipline be independent? The only independent candidates in my view are those with no experience within a police force. They would be going there with a totally independent approach. A candidate in my opinion with considerable experience necessary in overseeing a police authority would be Mr Hamish Sandison, a lawyer of many years standing, independent and capable enough to challenge a Chief Constable. I fail to see how someone that has been in a police force for many years can be totally independent in mind when challenging a Chief Constable on the running of the organisation.

Cllr Jim Higginson, Severn Ward, Caldicot

Comments (1)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

3:03pm Tue 30 Oct 12

Cwmderi says...

Jim (Sorry, Labour Councillor Higginson)
Great pity you did not take the opportunity to attend the hustings at Cwmbran a couple of weeks ago where all four candidates presented their credentials. If you had, you would have clearly witnessed that Mr Sandison the Labour Party funded candidate was anything but 'independent'.
He surrounded himself with some local Labour MPs, Labour affiliated trade union representatives and expounded the virtues of the Labour Party as it was only he and Labour who could save Gwent Police against the ravages of the Tories in London (a bit like King Canuet really), Think we've heard this line before from Labour politicians and yet we still come out a the bottom of the pile.
Sorry Jim, your argument simply does not hold water.
Jim (Sorry, Labour Councillor Higginson) Great pity you did not take the opportunity to attend the hustings at Cwmbran a couple of weeks ago where all four candidates presented their credentials. If you had, you would have clearly witnessed that Mr Sandison the Labour Party funded candidate was anything but 'independent'. He surrounded himself with some local Labour MPs, Labour affiliated trade union representatives and expounded the virtues of the Labour Party as it was only he and Labour who could save Gwent Police against the ravages of the Tories in London (a bit like King Canuet really), Think we've heard this line before from Labour politicians and yet we still come out a the bottom of the pile. Sorry Jim, your argument simply does not hold water. Cwmderi
  • Score: 0

Comments are closed on this article.

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree