Big companies 'let off by HMRC'

South Wales Argus: HMRC chief executive Lin Homer repeatedly denied entering negotiations with big companies over how much tax they would pay HMRC chief executive Lin Homer repeatedly denied entering negotiations with big companies over how much tax they would pay

The chairman of an influential Westminster spending watchdog has accused the tax authorities of letting large corporations off paying large sums of money.

In a bruising encounter at the Commons Public Accounts Committee, HM Revenue and Customs chief executive Lin Homer repeatedly denied entering negotiations with big companies over how much tax they would pay, insisting taxmen always sought to settle for the maximum sum they could hope to get if the case went to court.

But committee chairman Margaret Hodge said that there were "many question marks" hanging over the settlements reached in cases such as those involving Vodafone and Goldman Sachs, which have prompted widespread criticism of HMRC's approach.

Referring to the Vodafone case, when the communications giant agreed to pay £1.25 billion in tax arrears but was apparently not required to pay interest, Ms Hodge said: "It seems to me that you haven't pursued them properly and you have actually let them off a lot of tax."

And she said that Goldman Sachs had been "let off tens of millions".

In a report last December, the cross-party committee accused HMRC's outgoing permanent secretary for tax Dave Hartnett of striking "cosy deals" with some big companies. The allegation prompted an investigation by the National Audit Office which earlier this month found that, while there were shortcomings in HMRC's approach, the settlements reached in five large cases were "reasonable".

Ms Homer, who was appointed to lead HMRC in January this year, said she accepted criticisms relating to governance arrangements and was aiming to increase the number of commissioners with tax law qualifications from one to three or more, as well as to recruit as many as 1,000 tax-qualified graduates.

But she rejected suggestions that taxmen had done sweetheart deals with big companies, telling the committee: "We settle for the amount we think the Revenue is due. We do not settle for a lesser amount than we believe we could reasonably expect if we litigated."

Ms Hodge told the HMRC boss that her position was "incredible".

"It is the committee's view that there are so many question marks over whether the settlements are in the public interest and properly defend the taxpayer's interests and are fair and equal under the law," said Ms Hodge.

More national news stories

Comments (6)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

8:37pm Wed 27 Jun 12

old-codger says...

All at the expense of the poor and needy, I dont do vodaphone, Boots, Marks & Spencers and many more tax evading companies for the same reason. Large scale boycot is the answer to getting these people to pay up.
All at the expense of the poor and needy, I dont do vodaphone, Boots, Marks & Spencers and many more tax evading companies for the same reason. Large scale boycot is the answer to getting these people to pay up. old-codger

8:56pm Wed 27 Jun 12

Arthur says...

old-codger wrote:
All at the expense of the poor and needy, I dont do vodaphone, Boots, Marks & Spencers and many more tax evading companies for the same reason. Large scale boycot is the answer to getting these people to pay up.
So I'm not alone then!

Don't forget Amazon
[quote][p][bold]old-codger[/bold] wrote: All at the expense of the poor and needy, I dont do vodaphone, Boots, Marks & Spencers and many more tax evading companies for the same reason. Large scale boycot is the answer to getting these people to pay up.[/p][/quote]So I'm not alone then! Don't forget Amazon Arthur

8:57pm Wed 27 Jun 12

Arthur says...

old-codger wrote:
All at the expense of the poor and needy, I dont do vodaphone, Boots, Marks & Spencers and many more tax evading companies for the same reason. Large scale boycot is the answer to getting these people to pay up.
So I'm not alone then!

Don't forget Amazon
[quote][p][bold]old-codger[/bold] wrote: All at the expense of the poor and needy, I dont do vodaphone, Boots, Marks & Spencers and many more tax evading companies for the same reason. Large scale boycot is the answer to getting these people to pay up.[/p][/quote]So I'm not alone then! Don't forget Amazon Arthur

10:39pm Wed 27 Jun 12

Mr_Right says...

...and Dave "We're All In This Together" Cameron had the audacity to call Jimmy Carr immoral. Unbelievable.
...and Dave "We're All In This Together" Cameron had the audacity to call Jimmy Carr immoral. Unbelievable. Mr_Right

10:39pm Wed 27 Jun 12

Mr_Right says...

...and Dave "We're All In This Together" Cameron had the audacity to call Jimmy Carr immoral. Unbelievable.
...and Dave "We're All In This Together" Cameron had the audacity to call Jimmy Carr immoral. Unbelievable. Mr_Right

12:00am Thu 28 Jun 12

mouthalmighty says...

Disgraceful, but not surprising. Will this way of life ever cease to exist. I think not. Basically the rich get richer xnd the poor get poorer.
Disgraceful, but not surprising. Will this way of life ever cease to exist. I think not. Basically the rich get richer xnd the poor get poorer. mouthalmighty
Post a comment

Remember you are personally responsible for what you post on this site and must abide by our site terms. Do not post anything that is false, abusive or malicious. If you wish to complain, please use the ‘report this post’ link.

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree