MICHAEL PEARLMAN SAYS: Bale is just a diving patsy, it's the rules that need to change

First published in Sport

ANOTHER round of Premier League fixtures and again we have a ‘did he?’ diving debate on the crown jewel of Welsh football, Gareth Bale.

This time the tumbling Tottenham winger was booked for simulation at the Stadium of Light and as a result he misses today’s clash with Reading after picking up three successive yellow cards for impersonating Tom Daley.

If there is flippancy to that description it’s entirely merited because the current system for dealing with this absolute scourge of the game is fatally flawed, to the point of being entirely useless.

These aren’t the rantings of a bitter Spurs fan, rather the opinion of someone with an ounce of common sense. But you can be the judge of that.

Bale’s booking at Sunderland was in many ways the worst miscarriage of justice yet for a player whose card has now been well and truly marked.

It was a penalty. The contact on Bale looked minimal on first glance - a hand across the midriff - but on replay it is clear he takes a pretty full contact to the knee and is knocked off balance.

It is impossible to explain why a player at the peak of his powers and in the form of his career, on the back of a first Premier League hat-trick, would fall over when he’s clean through on goal.

A shot at goal for Bale would of course be preferable to him than Emmanuel Adebayor taking a penalty.

Referee Martin Atkinson made a mistake, booking Bale when another player would’ve been simply told to get to his feet.

That’s an opinion that can be proved, because at the end of the first half in the same game Jermain Defoe was guilty of one of the worst dives you’ll ever see. He wasn’t booked.

Contrast that to the recent game at the Emirates between Arsenal and West Brom.

Santi Cazorla dives for a penalty, the referee gives it, Arsenal go on to win the game. Cazorla’s punishment is three points and possibly an assist bonus.

That’s because the Football Association hamper themselves in dealing adequately with the issue of diving.

Firstly, there must be retrospective action taken against divers whose offences are missed by the official.

Cazorla and Defoe should be retrospectively booked for their dives. Bale should’ve been retrospectively booked for an earlier offence this season.

Similarly it is time the FA relinquished this absurd block on teams being able to appeal incorrect yellow cards.

Three times now Bale has been incorrectly booked because it’s been decided that, like Luis Suarez; he falls too dramatically and too easily.

I wouldn’t disagree that he doesn’t help himself, but Bale should not be serving a suspension.

It’s unfair on him and the supporters who have paid to watch him play. And each individual occurrence must be treated on its merits.

A point in case is Theo Walcott. At Wigan over Christmas he won a game-winning penalty going down very, very easily but on Saturday against Newcastle waltzed through a definite foul on him to sublimely chip home a hat-trick goal.

Possible diver to bravely staying on his feet in the space of one fixture.

No player is a complete cheat but very few players don’t at times look to gain an unfair advantage through simulation - that’s the reality of football as we head into 2013.

Gareth Bale is nothing more than the Cristiano Ronaldo or Didier Drogba of his day, a player under greater scrutiny of a widespread problem.

So it’s time for the FA to act accordingly.

They need to make fundamental changes to how they deal with diving in order to add fairness to an issue affecting every club in every game.

The need for retrospective punishment and an ability to overturn refereeing mistakes has become essential and until it is introduced the issue isn’t going to change an iota in British football.

Comments (4)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

11:41am Tue 1 Jan 13

casto says...

they all dive.but bales welsh.and isnt very good at it.lol
they all dive.but bales welsh.and isnt very good at it.lol casto
  • Score: 0

12:32pm Tue 1 Jan 13

st juliano says...

Any footballer can be booked for a dive that wasn't it's just bad luck, but bales been booked four times this season for diving so make of that what you will.
Any footballer can be booked for a dive that wasn't it's just bad luck, but bales been booked four times this season for diving so make of that what you will. st juliano
  • Score: 0

12:45pm Tue 1 Jan 13

NakedDancer says...

Bale was touched and arguably at that speed it would knock him off balance.

Like some other players though I think he's made a problem for himself admitting that if he's touched he'll go down. A touch isn't necessarily a foul and he's a big strong lad.

He'd destroyed the defender and if he'd made any attempt not to fall over he would have got the pen or scored anyway. We see him riding those challenges all over the pitch but in the box players are determined to throw themselves dramatically to the floor.

Surely its easy to punish the blatant cheats like the dive by Dafoe with no-one around him - an automatic 3 match ban as per a red card.
Bale was touched and arguably at that speed it would knock him off balance. Like some other players though I think he's made a problem for himself admitting that if he's touched he'll go down. A touch isn't necessarily a foul and he's a big strong lad. He'd destroyed the defender and if he'd made any attempt not to fall over he would have got the pen or scored anyway. We see him riding those challenges all over the pitch but in the box players are determined to throw themselves dramatically to the floor. Surely its easy to punish the blatant cheats like the dive by Dafoe with no-one around him - an automatic 3 match ban as per a red card. NakedDancer
  • Score: 0

7:46pm Thu 10 Jan 13

welshmen says...

I am Glad the PATSY plays for Wales...MICK...
I am Glad the PATSY plays for Wales...MICK... welshmen
  • Score: 0

Comments are closed on this article.

Send us your news, pictures and videos

Most read stories

Local Info

Enter your postcode, town or place name

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree