Parents and staff should have a say on the future of a Caerphilly County Borough school, which may close down next September because of budget problems, councillors have agreed.
Deri Primary School currently has 55 pupils enrolled, but one in eight are from outside the catchment area, and just two pupils have joined the nursery this year.
Amid projections of falling birth rates, surplus places at the school could rise to 60% in five years’ time.
Caerphilly Council’s education committee heard the proposal to consult on closing the school was brought to the local authority by the governing body, who “weren’t able to balance their budget based on the number of pupils coming forward”.
“We have live birth data from the health authority and we analyse the health data based on the catchment area where the children live,” explained senior education officer Andrea West. “We can see the parental preference along with the birth rates are falling, because the number of children coming into the school is far lower than the number of children expected to leave in Years 5 and 6.”
Cllr John Roberts said he felt “a great sadness” at the prospect the school could close, and urged decision-makers to consider both “head and heart”.
“I just feel for the parents and guardians, the teaching staff and especially the governors of Deri – it’s a village school,” he said.
“We might not think that almost 50 children is a lot, but almost 50 children being moved out of their village to another village, I think it’s a great shame.”
Cllr Roberts said he also feared other schools may have to close in future because of birth rates, which are a key factor in deciding how much funding each school receives.
Director of education Paul Warren accepted it was a “contentious issue” and “there are a number of surplus places across Caerphilly that we have to address”.
However, he said the committee should be “reassured” that former pupils of the borough’s Rhydri Primary, which closed in July 2025 because of budget problems linked to birth rates, had made “very successful starts in their new schools”.
“Just to give you a flavour of life within Deri Primary, you have two classes – one class is nursery up to Year 2 – and then you’ve got a Year 3 up to Year 6,” said Mr Warren.
“That’s a lot of age groups within two classes,” he said. “We’ve got to bring it back to [whether we are] really delivering the best offer for the children, based on the constrained financial circumstances the school has.
“We all understand it’s a very unfortunate circumstance and nobody would even want to be discussing potential consultation around closure, but the reality is day-to-day we’ve got to provide the best experiences for our learners.”
Officers were keen to point out no decision had been made on the future of Deri Primary – and would not be made without a formal consultation period.
Replying to questions from councillors Charlotte Bishop and Marina Chacon-Dawson on parent and pupil reaction, Ms West said the school community would have an opportunity to comment if the council’s cabinet agrees to launch the consultation.
Meanwhile, Cllr Elizabeth Aldworth said it was “very significant” the council had recognised the importance of a memorial to Mason Jones, a Deri Primary pupil who died in 2005 after eating E.coli-infected meat in school.
A committee report states that if the closure is agreed, the council will “engage directly with the family concerned to understand and accommodate their preferences regarding the future of the memorial, including potential relocation within the local community or to another suitable location of their choosing”.
Share