THE EDUCATION FILE: Llantarnam school changes 'will be swift'

THE EDUCATION FILE: Llantarnam school changes 'will be swift'

SPECIAL MEASURES: Llantarnam Comprehensive School

‘OPTIMISTIC’: Mark Provis

First published in News South Wales Argus: Photograph of the Author by

A TORFAEN school, Llantarnam Comprehensive School, is in special measures just months after the authority’s education department narrowly escaped the same fate. Education director Mark Provis talks about the authority’s plans for improvement.

WITH a failing school and education department, Torfaen council has a lot of work to do.

Last week Llantarnam Comprehensive School was put into special measures after inspectors Estyn said its current performance and prospects for improvement were “unsatisfactory”.

It said GCSE pupils’ performance was lower than similar schools, incidents of bullying were increasing, pupil behaviour was poor and senior management roles were not defined. It also said marking was inconsistent, only a minority of teachers planned lessons well, and few knew how to properly manage bad behaviour.

The school must now draw up an action plan and Estyn inspectors will continue to monitor the school each term until it is judged to have improved.

Just months earlier, the council’s own education department was judged as needing “significant improvement” because performance in the borough’s secondary schools had not improved in 2011.

Too many of its schools are in the bottom quarter for performance when compared to similar schools, and the percentage of 16-year-olds not in education, employment or training is too high, they said.

The department was also criticised for the rising number of fixed-term exclusions, and its pupil referral unit has also been identified as needing significant improvement in the last year.

Torfaen’s chief officer for education, Mark Provis, is the man tasked with turning it all around.

Following February’s report on the education, an overarching improvement board, chaired by the council leader, Bob Wellington, with external representatives from the Welsh Government and the Welsh Local Government Association, was set up.

They meet every two months and have helped compile an action plan, which is to be submitted to Estyn in January, setting out how the department will improve.

Two other boards, made up of governors, teachers, head teachers and school improvement specialists, meet monthly to scrutinise ongoing performance.

With the help of the new Gwent-wide Education Achievement Service (EAS) launched in September and Torfaen council’s own education partnership guide - published before the inspection in October, Mr Provis believes they are well placed to improve.

The guide aims to make sure all schools are working from a shared framework to improve consistency, while the EAS is a collaboration between Gwent’s local authority that will share good practice in a bid to raise standards.

Meanwhile, at Llantarnam Comprehensive School, immediate action was taken to address concerns raised about pupil safety and behaviour.

New fences have been installed to make it easier for staff to monitor children entering and leaving the site, while additional governors will be appointed on the request of existing ones, to give support.

Someone will also be appointed to assist head teacher David Bright to help iron out issues raised within the senior management of the school, but Mr Provis said he could not say if the long-term leadership of the school would change in future.

Typically, schools take around two years to come out of special measures but Mr Provis said he expected to see significant improvement at Llantarnam in about a year.

He said: “We can be optimistic about where it (the school) is going. It knows what it needs to do to – to develop a strong performance culture – and it is working to achieve that.

“This is very do-able, it’s very achievable, partly because of the self awareness of the governors, everybody is committed to do something about it. There’s no denial in this and no lack of willingness to address these issues.

“They were all shocked and surprised and ready to address the problems.

“As a result I am very supportive of them – they can really make a difference there.”

Minister calls for a review of the system

LAST week education minister Leighton Andrews called for a review into how education services are delivered.

It will look at whether they should merged under joint management by different councils, if they should be delivered regionally or should be removed from local government control to be directly accountable to Welsh Government. It will also examine whether schools should be directly funded by Welsh ministers.

In Gwent, Newport’s education department was found to be good, Blaenau Gwent is being run by commissioners after being put in special measures and Caerphilly’s was deemed adequate.

Inspectors focusing on improvements

ONCE a school is identified as requiring special measures, inspectors Estyn will inform the Welsh Government.

The school’s governing body and the local authority must form an action plan to Estyn for approval.

A small team of inspectors will then visit the school every term following the publication of the inspection report.

Inspectors will focus on the progress the school has made towards addressing the recommendations highlighted in the report. They will visit classes, talk to staff and pupils and look at documentation.

If the team judges the school has made enough progress towards achieving the recommendations, Estyn will recommend to HM Chief Inspector that it is removed from the list of schools requiring special measures.

If progress is insufficient Estyn will continue to until such progress is proved, with most schools removed from special measures within two years.

If Estyn continues to report unsatisfactory progress, education minister Leighton Andrews may take control of the school.

Comments (6)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

5:26pm Wed 28 Nov 12

spice15 says...

To be honest I cannot see Llantarnam School coming out of special measure in two years, let alone one. This school has spiraled downhill over the past 6-8 years or so. I have taken up issues myself with the education authorities many times with concerns with both my children in that school, nothing was done. I had to have private lessons in English and Mathematics to bring them upto standard to actually sit a GCSE then A levels - it was only due to this my two came out with a grade in these subjects. Maybe they should take a leaf out of St Josephs school in Newport - brilliant results! That is where my grandson will be going for sure.
To be honest I cannot see Llantarnam School coming out of special measure in two years, let alone one. This school has spiraled downhill over the past 6-8 years or so. I have taken up issues myself with the education authorities many times with concerns with both my children in that school, nothing was done. I had to have private lessons in English and Mathematics to bring them upto standard to actually sit a GCSE then A levels - it was only due to this my two came out with a grade in these subjects. Maybe they should take a leaf out of St Josephs school in Newport - brilliant results! That is where my grandson will be going for sure. spice15
  • Score: 0

7:40pm Wed 28 Nov 12

truthpeace says...

these I read in the report in the South Wales Argus that Mr Bright was "very upset" at the findings of the inspectors. I wonder how many parents' hearts sank whenwhen they read it? Mr Bright, the governors and the senior staff have all had their education, and these pupils only get one crack at it. This is now a massive problem for these children. These members of staff can move on, goodness knows where after this report, but the children's exprience of education may have been ruined. I think the same applies to the local authority which has also failed these pupils. These failing schools should be taken out of the hands of the Welsh Assembly Government. Is it possible that the problem is far too big for them to deal with ? Westminister should take over the reins. Mr Bright and the governors should now resign and the local authority it's leadership and education department needs a good shake up.
Now for the nitty gritty. Is this a smoke screen as the land at Llantarnam School would hold a lot of houses. Why have this been allowed to go on for so long?
these I read in the report in the South Wales Argus that Mr Bright was "very upset" at the findings of the inspectors. I wonder how many parents' hearts sank whenwhen they read it? Mr Bright, the governors and the senior staff have all had their education, and these pupils only get one crack at it. This is now a massive problem for these children. These members of staff can move on, goodness knows where after this report, but the children's exprience of education may have been ruined. I think the same applies to the local authority which has also failed these pupils. These failing schools should be taken out of the hands of the Welsh Assembly Government. Is it possible that the problem is far too big for them to deal with ? Westminister should take over the reins. Mr Bright and the governors should now resign and the local authority it's leadership and education department needs a good shake up. Now for the nitty gritty. Is this a smoke screen as the land at Llantarnam School would hold a lot of houses. Why have this been allowed to go on for so long? truthpeace
  • Score: 0

8:01pm Wed 28 Nov 12

truthpeace says...

I read in the report in the South Wales Argus that Mr Bright was "very upset" at the findings of the inspectors. I wonder how many parents' hearts sank whenwhen they read it? Mr Bright, the governors and the senior staff have all had their education, and these pupils only get one crack at it. This is now a massive problem for these children. These members of staff can move on, goodness knows where after this report, but the children's exprience of education may have been ruined. I think the same applies to the local authority which has also failed these pupils. These failing schools should be taken out of the hands of the Welsh Assembly Government. Is it possible that the problem is far too big for them to deal with ? Westminister should take over the reins. Mr Bright and the governors should now resign and the local authority it's leadership and education department needs a good shake up. Why have this been allowed to go on for so long.
Now for the nitty gritty. Is this a smoke screen as the land at Llantarnam School would hold a lot of houses. ( copy corrected).
I read in the report in the South Wales Argus that Mr Bright was "very upset" at the findings of the inspectors. I wonder how many parents' hearts sank whenwhen they read it? Mr Bright, the governors and the senior staff have all had their education, and these pupils only get one crack at it. This is now a massive problem for these children. These members of staff can move on, goodness knows where after this report, but the children's exprience of education may have been ruined. I think the same applies to the local authority which has also failed these pupils. These failing schools should be taken out of the hands of the Welsh Assembly Government. Is it possible that the problem is far too big for them to deal with ? Westminister should take over the reins. Mr Bright and the governors should now resign and the local authority it's leadership and education department needs a good shake up. Why have this been allowed to go on for so long. Now for the nitty gritty. Is this a smoke screen as the land at Llantarnam School would hold a lot of houses. ( copy corrected). truthpeace
  • Score: 0

10:48pm Wed 28 Nov 12

Np207yb says...

What I want to ask someone is this: Can the parents of those children who have been failed by Llantarnam School seek legal compensation for lives and futures that have been messed up by years of poor teaching?

Time for an outcry of how badly a whole generation has been failed. After all we pay the taxes thay employ these people.

If anything like this was happening to my daughter (who goes to Newport High) I would be shouting from the rooftops as much as I could.

Hopefully there wont be any kneejerk reactions to this and waste even more money.
What I want to ask someone is this: Can the parents of those children who have been failed by Llantarnam School seek legal compensation for lives and futures that have been messed up by years of poor teaching? Time for an outcry of how badly a whole generation has been failed. After all we pay the taxes thay employ these people. If anything like this was happening to my daughter (who goes to Newport High) I would be shouting from the rooftops as much as I could. Hopefully there wont be any kneejerk reactions to this and waste even more money. Np207yb
  • Score: 0

8:06pm Thu 29 Nov 12

bolney64 says...

truthpeace wrote:
I read in the report in the South Wales Argus that Mr Bright was "very upset" at the findings of the inspectors. I wonder how many parents' hearts sank whenwhen they read it? Mr Bright, the governors and the senior staff have all had their education, and these pupils only get one crack at it. This is now a massive problem for these children. These members of staff can move on, goodness knows where after this report, but the children's exprience of education may have been ruined. I think the same applies to the local authority which has also failed these pupils. These failing schools should be taken out of the hands of the Welsh Assembly Government. Is it possible that the problem is far too big for them to deal with ? Westminister should take over the reins. Mr Bright and the governors should now resign and the local authority it's leadership and education department needs a good shake up. Why have this been allowed to go on for so long.
Now for the nitty gritty. Is this a smoke screen as the land at Llantarnam School would hold a lot of houses. ( copy corrected).
You are spot on! All of this is a smokescreen to close Llantarnam and build houses on the site.

MARK PROVIS NEEDS TO BE SACKED.

He will not turn anything around at Llantarnam - he wants to CLOSE it and merge the Cwmbran schools into one academy to 'raise standards' in his failing local authority.

What we are witnessing at Llantarnam is a witch hunt by Provis, who wants the head out so that he can do what he has always wanted to - combine all Cwmbran schools into one 'superschool'. He will close one of the existing schools (Fairwater, Croesyceiliog, Llantarnam) in the process by blaming 'falling rolls and low standards' and all our kids will suffer.

This problem is not restricted to Llantarnam - EVERY SCHOOL in Probis' area is failing and he should be sacked. Instead he removes headteachers one by one to stop them challenging his destructive, ill-conceived plan for the town's schools. It is no coincidence that the head of Fairwater was sacked, the head of Croesyceiliog resigned and now the head of Llantarnam will go.

In Provis' plan, pupils will be forced into a 'one size fits all' environment which will fail even more of them. Behaviour will be even worse when our kids become just one more face in a huge institution with larger class sizes, more disruption and even bigger social problems.

Mr Bright is the only one who can fight the school's corner but it may already be too late - I have a friend on the Governing Body who told me that they have been threatened by Mark Provis that they will be replaced if they do not back him and his plan and abandon support for the head.

WE MUST SPEAK OUT TO SUPPORT THE SCHOOL NOW.
[quote][p][bold]truthpeace[/bold] wrote: I read in the report in the South Wales Argus that Mr Bright was "very upset" at the findings of the inspectors. I wonder how many parents' hearts sank whenwhen they read it? Mr Bright, the governors and the senior staff have all had their education, and these pupils only get one crack at it. This is now a massive problem for these children. These members of staff can move on, goodness knows where after this report, but the children's exprience of education may have been ruined. I think the same applies to the local authority which has also failed these pupils. These failing schools should be taken out of the hands of the Welsh Assembly Government. Is it possible that the problem is far too big for them to deal with ? Westminister should take over the reins. Mr Bright and the governors should now resign and the local authority it's leadership and education department needs a good shake up. Why have this been allowed to go on for so long. Now for the nitty gritty. Is this a smoke screen as the land at Llantarnam School would hold a lot of houses. ( copy corrected).[/p][/quote]You are spot on! All of this is a smokescreen to close Llantarnam and build houses on the site. MARK PROVIS NEEDS TO BE SACKED. He will not turn anything around at Llantarnam - he wants to CLOSE it and merge the Cwmbran schools into one academy to 'raise standards' in his failing local authority. What we are witnessing at Llantarnam is a witch hunt by Provis, who wants the head out so that he can do what he has always wanted to - combine all Cwmbran schools into one 'superschool'. He will close one of the existing schools (Fairwater, Croesyceiliog, Llantarnam) in the process by blaming 'falling rolls and low standards' and all our kids will suffer. This problem is not restricted to Llantarnam - EVERY SCHOOL in Probis' area is failing and he should be sacked. Instead he removes headteachers one by one to stop them challenging his destructive, ill-conceived plan for the town's schools. It is no coincidence that the head of Fairwater was sacked, the head of Croesyceiliog resigned and now the head of Llantarnam will go. In Provis' plan, pupils will be forced into a 'one size fits all' environment which will fail even more of them. Behaviour will be even worse when our kids become just one more face in a huge institution with larger class sizes, more disruption and even bigger social problems. Mr Bright is the only one who can fight the school's corner but it may already be too late - I have a friend on the Governing Body who told me that they have been threatened by Mark Provis that they will be replaced if they do not back him and his plan and abandon support for the head. WE MUST SPEAK OUT TO SUPPORT THE SCHOOL NOW. bolney64
  • Score: 1

5:45pm Sat 1 Dec 12

marc44 says...

Cannot belive mr probis is suprized by this the school is rubbish and does need to be shut down and a new school put in place that is not damp and does not smell of urine . Maybe then the teachers may take pride in their jobs and try to sort out the mess.
Cannot belive mr probis is suprized by this the school is rubbish and does need to be shut down and a new school put in place that is not damp and does not smell of urine . Maybe then the teachers may take pride in their jobs and try to sort out the mess. marc44
  • Score: 0

Comments are closed on this article.

Send us your news, pictures and videos

Most read stories

Local Info

Enter your postcode, town or place name

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree