Councillor angered by solar farm decision

First published in Gwent news by

A MONMOUTHSHIRE county councillor has attacked his colleagues’ decision to pass plans for a 32,000-panel solar farm just north of the Wentwood Reservoir.

Cllr Graham Down, who represents Shirenewton on the council, told its planning committee the plans presented to them last Tuesday , August 5, amounted to “rural vandalism”. He said the panels will destroy the area’s scenic beauty for the 25 years they will be based at Buckwell Farm in Pen-y-Cae Mawr.

He said: “The first issue with the application was the timing. Three members of the community were away and they have school aged children. The result might well have been different (if they were there). It is silly, it is absurd, it is ridiculous.”

But Monmouthshire council has said no application has unfair weight given for or against it by being heard during the summer months.

And Cllr Down said points raised by two committee members, Cllrs Phil Murphy and Roger Harris, that people do not necessarily notice them on a motorway was a flawed comparison because the farm will be built away from any motorways and in the Monmouthshire countryside.

Cllr Down added: “Their contention that was you do not notice them. If you’re driving at 70 miles per hour you don’t notice them. It is not the same as staring at a solar farm of 30,000 panels.

“The only community benefit coming out of this is an education provision so they can bring Welsh children there. There is absolutely nothing for the community at large.”

And he added he had asked the decision to be withheld for the time being because of what he said were “irregularities and omissions” in the planning process.

The solar farm plan was submitted by the Llancayo-based Buckle Chamberlain Partnership, who have said the development will power 2,120 homes, saving 3,286 tonnes of carbon dioxide emissions every year.

Before the meeting last week, opponents to the scheme had said they were worried pylons stretching from Wentwood to Caldicot would need to be built to transfer the electricity harvested by the panels. But a Buckle Chamberlain Partnership representative told the meeting last week that he could not foresee see the need for any pylons to be built.

And Monmouth MP David Davies previously said that he had concerns about the plan because of the potentially high expense of buying back electricity harvested by the solar panels.

Comments (5)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

12:04pm Fri 15 Aug 14

welshmen says...

What a waste of space, any thing to make money for the fat cats, never mind the people who live and like walking there it's all about money, nothing else, if carbon dioxide is the Satan why doesn't the Government build the Seven Barrage, they don't because they like the donations that are made to their Parties Coffers from the likes of these Companies....
What a waste of space, any thing to make money for the fat cats, never mind the people who live and like walking there it's all about money, nothing else, if carbon dioxide is the Satan why doesn't the Government build the Seven Barrage, they don't because they like the donations that are made to their Parties Coffers from the likes of these Companies.... welshmen
  • Score: 5

4:39pm Fri 15 Aug 14

Martyn Butler says...

118 ACRES of Glass soaking up the sun and giving us Green Energy - AWESOME

HOWEVER PLEASE SACK the IDIOTS that chose not to built greenhouses to do the very same thing and create jobs in a much needed agricultural region. This is PRIME Agricultural land - some of the very best on planet earth -
To turn it over to Energy Only is nothing short of criminal.

#voteforchange #green #solar #renewport
118 ACRES of Glass soaking up the sun and giving us Green Energy - AWESOME HOWEVER PLEASE SACK the IDIOTS that chose not to built greenhouses to do the very same thing and create jobs in a much needed agricultural region. This is PRIME Agricultural land - some of the very best on planet earth - To turn it over to Energy Only is nothing short of criminal. #voteforchange #green #solar #renewport Martyn Butler
  • Score: 9

6:09pm Fri 15 Aug 14

Sid Bonkers says...

All the Councillors who voted for this at this location should be chucked off the Council. Shame on you.
All the Councillors who voted for this at this location should be chucked off the Council. Shame on you. Sid Bonkers
  • Score: 2

11:09am Tue 19 Aug 14

Good Job No Kids says...

welshmen wrote:
What a waste of space, any thing to make money for the fat cats, never mind the people who live and like walking there it's all about money, nothing else, if carbon dioxide is the Satan why doesn't the Government build the Seven Barrage, they don't because they like the donations that are made to their Parties Coffers from the likes of these Companies....
The severn barrage was estimated at 30 billion pounds? Where is that money going to come from?

Don't you think if this was viable, potential companies would be throwing donations around like confetti?

You post is ill informed opinionated nonsense.
[quote][p][bold]welshmen[/bold] wrote: What a waste of space, any thing to make money for the fat cats, never mind the people who live and like walking there it's all about money, nothing else, if carbon dioxide is the Satan why doesn't the Government build the Seven Barrage, they don't because they like the donations that are made to their Parties Coffers from the likes of these Companies....[/p][/quote]The severn barrage was estimated at 30 billion pounds? Where is that money going to come from? Don't you think if this was viable, potential companies would be throwing donations around like confetti? You post is ill informed opinionated nonsense. Good Job No Kids
  • Score: 0

11:12am Tue 19 Aug 14

Good Job No Kids says...

There is already one in the countryside at Llancayo and unless your commute by plane or helicopter you would have no idea it is there.

Typical whinging nimby's not happy unless they have something to whinge about.
There is already one in the countryside at Llancayo and unless your commute by plane or helicopter you would have no idea it is there. Typical whinging nimby's not happy unless they have something to whinge about. Good Job No Kids
  • Score: 0

Comments are closed on this article.

Send us your news, pictures and videos

Most read stories

Local Info

Enter your postcode, town or place name

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree